SET VS. SELECT in SQL Server

Chikul
Posted by in Sql Server category on for Beginner level | Views : 6056 red flag

SET and SELECT both key words are used to Assign Variables in SQL Server.

SET and SELECT both specifies the columns to be changed and the new values for the columns.
The values in the specified columns are updated with the values specified in the SET and SELECT in all rows that match the WHERE clause search condition.
If no WHERE clause is specified, all rows are updated.
Introduction

SET and SELECT both key words are used to Assign Variables in SQL Server.

SET and SELECT both specifies the columns to be changed and the new values for the columns.
The values in the specified columns are updated with the values specified in the SET and SELECT in all rows that match the WHERE clause search condition.
If no WHERE clause is specified, all rows are updated.

There are some difference based on the Performance, Process like Follows :

1. SET is the ANSI standard for variable assignment, SELECT is not. 

2. SELECT can be used to assign values to more than one variable at a time, Whereas SET allows to assign data to only one variable at a time.

Example :

/* Declaring variables */
DECLARE @Var1 AS int, @Var2 AS int

/* The same can be done using SET, but two SET statements are needed */
SET @Var1 = 1
SET @Var2 = 2  

/* Initializing two variables at once */
SELECT @Var1 = 1, @Var2 = 2

But use SET instead SELECT, for variable initialization, It will throw the following error

SET @Var1 = 1, @Var2 = 2  

Msg 102, Level 15, State 1, Line 10
Incorrect syntax near ','.

3. When assigning from a query if there is no value returned then SET will assign NULL, where SELECT will not make the assignment at all .so the variable will not be changed from it's previous value.  

Example :

Run it in master Database in SQL Server.

/* Returns NULL */
DECLARE @Title varchar(80)
--SET @Title = 'Not Found'

SET @Title =
(
SELECT error
FROM SysMessages
WHERE Description = 'Invalid Description'
)

SELECT @Title
GO

/* Returns the string literal 'Not Found' */
DECLARE @Title varchar(80)
SET @Title = 'Not Found'

SELECT @Title = error
FROM SysMessages
WHERE Description = 'Invalid Description'

SELECT @Title
GO  

4. Let using a query needs to populate a variable and the Query returns more than one value.
SET will fail with an error in this scenario.
But SELECT will assign one of the returned rows and mask the fact that the query returned more than one row.

As a result, bugs in your the could go unnoticed with SELECT, and this type of bugs is hard to track down too.

Example :

/* Consider the following table with two rows */
SET NOCOUNT ON
CREATE TABLE #Table (i int, j varchar(10))
INSERT INTO #Table (i, j) VALUES (1, 'Sunday')
INSERT INTO #Table (i, j) VALUES (1, 'Monday')
GO

/* Following SELECT will return two rows, but the variable gets its value from one of those rows, without an error.
you will never know that two rows existed for the condition, WHERE i = 1 */
DECLARE @j varchar(10)
SELECT @j = j FROM #Table WHERE i = 1
SELECT @j
GO

/* If you rewrite the same query, but use SET instead, for variable initialization, you will see the following error */
DECLARE @j varchar(10)
SET @j = (SELECT j FROM #Table WHERE i = 1)
SELECT @j

Msg 512, Level 16, State 1, Line 4
Subquery returned more than 1 value. This is not permitted when the subquery follows =, !=, <, <= , >, >= or when the subquery is used as an expression.

Based on the above results, when using a query to populate variables, we should always use SET.
If you want to be sure that only one row is returned then only use SELECT, as shown below:

DECLARE @j varchar(10)
SELECT @j = (SELECT j FROM #Table WHERE i = 1)
SELECT @j

5. This very feature of SELECT makes it a winner over SET, when assigning values to multiple variables. A single SELECT statement assigning values to 3 different variables, is much faster than 3 different SET statements assigning values to 3 different variables.
In this scenario, using a SELECT is at least twice as fast, compared to SET.

So, the conclusion is, if there is a loop in th stored procedure that manipulates the values of several variables, and if you want to squeeze as much performance as possible out of this loop, then do all variable manipulations in one single SELECT statement or group the related variables into few SELECT statements as show below:

SELECT @Var1 = @Var1 + 1, @Var2 = @Var2 - 1, @CNT = @CNT + 1

Page copy protected against web site content infringement by Copyscape

About the Author

Chikul
Full Name: Prasanti Prusty
Member Level: Bronze
Member Status: Member
Member Since: 11/20/2009 10:34:27 PM
Country: India

http://knowledgeparlour.blogspot.com/

Login to vote for this post.

Comments or Responses

Login to post response

Comment using Facebook(Author doesn't get notification)